In the last few days the West of England Combined Authority (WECA) and Bristol City Council (BCC) have made public more details about transport planning in the area, including a bus-based rapid transit network and the as yet mode-agnostic mass transit system.
At the BCC Scrutiny Meeting on Thursday 11th March, Adam Crowther (BCC Head of Transport) gave a presentation outlining plans for a bus-based rapid transit network. These routes are part of the first set of medium term rapid transit schemes, designed to bring incremental improvement to the city’s transport network during over the next 5-10 years.
Medium-term rapid transit bus network
The routes are:
- Portway Park and Ride to Hicks Gate Park and Ride via A4
- Long Ashton Park and Ride to M32 Park and Ride (which does not yet have an agreed site)
- Hengrove to Cribbs Causeway via M32
- Stockwood to Cribbs Causeway via A37 and A4018 (a route already improved under the Bristol Bus Deal)
- Inner ring anti-clockwise orbital service (as it is easier to turn left!)
Adam indicated that the service would likely be delivered by a Belfast Glider equivalent vehicle. The Belfast Glider is a dual-unit (aka bendibus), low or zero emissions vehicle. These vehicles were described as superior to MetroBus double-deckers due to accessibility and being more tram-like in passenger experience.
Corridors will be “almost fully segregated”, particularly in the city centre, but not necessarily segregated for short stretches where there is little risk of congestion. Frequency of services were described as turn-up-and-go, so that there was little penalty when changing service.
Quality interchanges will allow local services, feeder services and orbital services to feed into the radial routes. Interchanges could act as mobility hubs to be the focus of local communities.
Underground, overground mass transit
On the same day Bristol Mayor Marvin Rees gave a press conference to present new information about the longer-term mass transit system, which is described as having some underground running.
The proposed routes are:
- Centre to Cribbs Causeway via Montpelier, Southmead, Filton North, YTL Arena, Aztec West, new A38 (north) Park and Ride
- Centre to Emersons Green via Old Market, Lawrence Hill, St George, Kingswood, Bristol & Bath Science Park
- Centre to Bath via Temple Meads, Arnos Vale, Keynsham
- Centre to Bristol Airport via Knowle, Hengrove, new A38 (south) Park and Ride
WECA have already made available £1.5m to look into options and routes for mass transit. The mass transit could cost up to £4 billion, with half the funding coming from Westminster. WECA have previously indicated that projects of this scale can take several years to design, approve and build so it may be 15-20 years before the mass transit system is completed.
Speaking of the technology to be used, Marvin said:
The underground would involve some tunnels and some surface travel, but the advantage of tunnels is that it’s segregated from traffic. We try to get people to stop thinking about a London underground big heavy rail-based option – you could be talking about light rail, we could be talking about some kind of segregated tram system, or you could be talking about pods on rubber wheels, basically driverless pods that follow white lines on the floor. That gives a lot more flexibility…the exact technology is yet to be confirmed.Marvin Rees, Bristol Mayor
The mass transit recommendation that FoSBR repeatedly hear is “don’t go underground”. One of the speakers at our January FoSBR AGM was Andrew Braddock of Bath & Bristol Trams who gave us several pearls of wisdom including: don’t dig an underground, public transport belongs in the streets, so take the private cars out. Tram introduction results in increased bus use due to interchange opportunities.
Andrew Braddock also described France’s experience of tram rejuvenation. In the last 34 years, France has inaugurated 28 new tram networks. The average time from inception to start of service in France is 6 years. Compare and contrast!
One FoSBR member commented on the risks for the rapid transit of being “almost” fully segregated: “Remember the ongoing problems with MetroBus getting stuck in traffic jams?”
Another FoSBR member made the following observation on mass transit: “I can get excited about a tram soon, but I can’t get excited about a bus after I’m dead.”
There will be a public consultation in summer 2021. A Strategic Outline Business Case is due to be completed by late 2021, this being the mechanism which forms the evidence base for the Government to decide whether to progress and fund the project.
We cannot expect BCC or WECA to unilaterally transform the glacial UK infrastructure planning process, so let’s engage positively with them.
Local rail postscript
At the Scrutiny meeting, Adam also confirmed the details of improvements for local rail, including:
- Half-hourly service to Avonmouth due December 2021, after completion of Bristol East Junction remodelling
- Portway Pank and Ride rail station due 2021, capacity of parking can be increased to 1200 if needed
- Portishead service due 2024
- Half-hourly service to Yate or Gloucester due 2023, or earlier
- Hourly service to Henbury due 2023, including access to new A4018 Park and Ride
- Ashley Down rail station due 2023
- St Annes station feasibility study ongoing as funded by Restoring Your Railways
- Ashton Gate and Horfield/Lockleaze were described as schemes that could emerge in 2020-2030